| Year | Sponsor | Student/Athlete | School |
| 2006 – – – – – |
Thrivent Thrivent Thrivent M&I Bank M&I Bank Friends of Danny Ornstein |
Amber Zdanovec Nathan Emanuel Natalie Andersen Brittany Jensen Kevin Rohrer Stephanie Sievers |
Appleton East Appleton North Appleton West Fox Valley Lutheran Xavier Xavier |
| 2007 – – – – – |
Thrivent Thrivent M&I Bank M&I Bank M&I Bank Friends of Danny Ornstein |
Steffani Stoeger Anna Johnson Marie Hoffman Mary Elizabeth Olson Michael Lindeke Logan Bernecker |
Fox Valley Lutheran Xavier Appleton East Appleton North Appleton West Xavier |
| 2008 – – – – – |
Thrivent Thrivent Thrivent M&I Bank M&I Bank Friends of Danny Ornstein |
Heidi Baerenwald Elliot Krause Ryan Pelky Tricia Matinke Maddie Drusch Eric Timm |
Appleton East Appleton North Appleton West Fox Valley Lutheran Xavier Fox Valley Lutheran |
| 2009 – – – – – |
Thrivent Thrivent M&I Bank M&I Bank M&I Bank Friends of Danny Ornstein |
Robin Nommensen Ashley Barwick David Salzwedel Amy Feivor Shane McQuade Patrick Stumpf |
Fox Valley Lutheran Xavier Appleton East Appleton North Appleton West Xavier |
| 2010 – – – – – |
Thrivent Thrivent Thrivent M&I Bank M&I Bank Friends of Danny Ornstein |
Erica Halley Tremayne Williams Willie Resop Alyssa Gresl Alek Brandenberg Julie VanDynHoven |
Appleton East Appleton North Appleton West Xavier Fox Valley Lutheran Xavier |
| 2011 – – – – – |
J. J. Keller Foundation J. J. Keller Foundation M&I Bank M&I Bank M&I Bank Friends of Danny Ornstein |
Benjamin Nommensen John Weyenberg Dan Schubert Rachel Weber Charlie Foss Michael Toll |
Fox Valley Lutheran Xavier Appleton East Appleton North Appleton West Fox Valley Lutheran |
| 2012 – – – – – |
M&I Bank M&I Bank J. J. Keller Foundation J. J. Keller Foundation J. J. Keller Foundation Friends of Danny Ornstein |
Marissa Michalkiewioz Kati Baker Tayler Hegg Erin Riley Kate Marie Weyenberg JDP Scholarship Fund |
Appleton East Appleton North Appleton West Fox Valley Lutheran Xavier Clintonville |
| 2013 – – – – – |
BMO Harris Bank BMO Harris Bank BMO Harris Bank J. J. Keller Foundation J. J. Keller Foundation Friends of Danny Ornstein |
Lauren Blasczyk Stephen Idlas Maggie Coughlin Chase Maxwell Ashley Bovee Karen Arndt |
Appleton East Appleton North Appleton West Fox Valley Lutheran Xavier Fox Valley Lutheran |
| 2014 – – – – – |
BMO Harris Bank BMO Harris Bank BMO Harris Bank J. J. Keller Foundation J. J. Keller Foundation Friends of Danny Ornstein |
Mackenzie Greisch Alan Lemons Matthew Reader Matt Ferris Abby Radue Brian Walsh |
Appleton North Appleton East Appleton West Xavier Fox Valley Lutheran Xavier |
| 2015 – – – – – |
BMO Harris Bank BMO Harris Bank BMO Harris Bank J. J. Keller Foundation J. J. Keller Foundation Friends of Danny Ornstein |
Emily Habeck Jeffrey Steers Emily Wypiszynski Danielle Vos Kyle Van Hammond Adrienne Fischer |
Appleton North Appleton East Appleton West Fox Valley Lutheran Xavier Fox Valley Lutheran |
| Year | Sponsor | Student/Athlete | School |
| 2016 – – – – – |
BMO Harris Bank BMO Harris Bank J. J. Keller Foundation J. J. Keller Foundation J. J. Keller Foundation Friends of Danny Ornstein |
Nicholas Vande Hey Alex Gerhardt Megan Schweitzer Grace Garvey Michaela Braun Mikayla Sipiorski |
Xavier Fox Valley Lutheran Appleton East Appleton North Appleton West Xavier |
| 2017 – – – – – |
SECURA Insurance SECURA Insurance SECURA Insurance J. J. Keller Foundation J. J. Keller Foundation Friends of Danny Ornstein |
Tricia Dailey Calypso Pohlman Joshua Nieves Samantha Birling Adam Drees Megan Glaeser |
Appleton East Appleton North Appleton West Fox Valley Lutheran Xavier Fox Valley Lutheran |
|
2018 – – – |
J. J. Keller Foundation SECURA Insurance Friends of Danny Ornstein
|
Lauren Lietzke Samuel Ferris Sor Kevin Thao |
Appleton West Xavier
|
|
2019 – – |
SECURA Insurance J. J. Keller Foundation
|
Lauren Vande Walle Emma Vosters
|
Appleton West Xavier Appleton West |